The Sociology of Business newsletter: the Cadence edit

Newsletter Challenge, v. 9

Quick note: I recently wrapped up a writing coach arrangement with Ari Lewis, host of the Mastering the Attention Economy podcast. We enjoyed working together (see Ari’s ROI here), and he proposed I take on a newsletter editing challenge.

The challenge: Twenty edits by 22 September.

My primary goal: add clarity, concision, and cadence to the newsletters, and sharpen up my own editing process. At the end of the challenge, I’ll provide reflections on each edit and offer some lessons you can use on your own newsletter.

For details on my process, click here, a Google doc. Leave suggestions as you see fit. Thanks!

The 4Cs of the Modern Brand, the Global Pandemic Edition,” Apr 20

@ https://andjelicaaa.substack.com/p/the-4cs-of-the-modern-brand-the-global by Ana Andjelic / @andjelicaaa

–Grey typeface: Ana.

Normal typeface: me.

Key metrics (original -> edit)
–reading level: 12 -> 10.
–word count: 1345 -> 1437
–median sentence length: 19 -> 14 words.
–sentence length, standard deviation (basically, a measure of the variety of sentence lengths): 11 -> 10.


“The 4Cs”: the Cadence edit

Helena Glazer is a fashion and beauty influencer who goes under Instagram handle @brooklynblonde1. On March 30th, she posted a photo of herself in the head-to-toe Everlane look, a mere couple of days after Everlane fired all of its union workers and was publicly called out for it by Bernie Sanders. Helena Glazer is a fashion and beauty influencer who goes under Instagram handle @brooklynblonde1. On March 30th, she posted a photo of herself in the head-to-toe Everlane look, a mere couple of days after Everlane fired all of its union workers and was publicly called out for it by Bernie Sanders. 

On March 30, fashion and beauty influencer Helena Glazer posted a photo of herself on Instagram fully clad in Everlane apparel and, nearly instantly, discovered the contemporary perils of cluelessness. Three days before, Everlane had fired their workers who were trying to unionize. Senator Bernie Sanders drew attention to the kerfuffle and rightly so, given Everlane’s tagline: “Our way: Exceptional quality. Ethical factories. Radical Transparency.”

~~~~~~

Both in her website post and in her Instagram comments, she was called out for supporting a brand with the obviously unethical practices. “Maybe reconsider supporting Everlane. They are under heat and controversy for laying off their workers for wanting to unionize, which says a lot about Everlane,” one Instagram comment read. “It’s hard for me to even consider buying anything from Everlane having in mind their latest choices and horrible behavior … It’s interesting to see how affiliate bloggers are gonna approach the situation,” was one of the comments on the Brooklyn Blonde website. Under pressure, BB later clarified in her Instagram Story that she was “not aware” of what happened and was under contractual obligation with Everlane to promote their products.

On Instagram and her website, Glazer got called out for supporting a brand with apparently shady ethics.

“Maybe reconsider supporting Everlane,” noted one Instagrammer “They are under heat and controversy for laying off their workers for wanting to unionize, which says a lot about Everlane.”

“It’s hard for me to even consider buying anything from Everlane having in mind their latest choices and horrible behavior,” noted a message on her website. “It’s interesting to see how affiliate bloggers are gonna approach the situation.”

Glazer later clarified that she was under contractual obligation to promote Everlane products and was “not aware” of their anti-union stance.

~~~~~~

These days, this particular kind of practiced cluelessness draws ire, as Page Six-labeled #covidiot Arielle Charnas experienced first hand. Almost overnight, consumers went through the cultural climate change and emerged on the other side more receptive to brands’ and influencers’ positive actions and more ready to scrutinize the perceived negative ones. Selfishness, insensitivity, inequality, lack of empathy and compassion, and failure to read the room are quickly socially shamed.

These days, this variety of practiced ignorance can be deadly for brands. Consider “#covidiot Arielle Charnas,” who, according to the New York Post, “used ‘her privilege’ to obtain one of the treasured [COVID] tests — even after she had said she didn’t meet the criteria.” Almost overnight, consumers went through this cultural climate sea change. Now, on the other side, they scrutinize the ethical actions of brands and influencers, and they’re instantly ready to shame those who traffic in selfishness, insensitivity, inequality, and lack of empathy.

~~~~~~

This is the new backdrop for brand strategy. Radical individualism is out, social connection is in. Brand focus is not on the end customer, but on the communities they belong to. Just as personas made individual consumers visible, the new brand methodology makes visible consumer communities and their co-dependencies and influences. New focus of engagement plans is not just on the brand actions, but on their secondary effects. Pre-pandemic consumer-centric brand strategy is now society-centric strategy.

Against this new backdrop, there are the 4Cs of the modern brand: community, content, curation, and collaborations. They impact how a company defines and executes their brand strategy, launches and markets its products and services, and captures, distributes and delivers value to its customers.

 Welcome to the new backdrop for brand strategy. Radical individualism is out. Social connection is in. Brand focus now shifts from the end customer to the communities they belong to. Just as personas made individual consumers visible, the new brand methodology makes visible consumer communities and their success in walking the walk. Engagement plans need to account for brand actions and their secondary effects. Consumer-centric brand strategy is so 2019. Society-centric strategy rules the era of COVID-19 (and after).

Let’s imagine there are 4 Cs for contemporary brands: community, content, curation, and collaborations. All four impact how

a company defines and executes their brand strategy,

launches and markets its products and services, and

captures, distributes and delivers value to its customers.

~~~~~~

Community. A brand community quickly went from a “nice to have” to a “must have.” It doesn’t matter what category a brand is in, it has to find a way to put forward its social mission and values, which are the gel for a community. For brands that already maintain communities, the next step is to activate it more, and more often. Marc Jacobs’ WFH and Drawn Together, and GANNI Talks are examples of capitalizing on a brand’s own creative community. Or, MeUndies is these days featuring customers willing to share selfies wearing MeUndies products on instagram. David Zwirner gallery partnered with the wider gallerists’ community and launched Platform: New York, an online initiative to feature artists from twelve NY-based galleries. Allure magazine activated its community of stylists, makeup artists, photographers, and hairstylists. Or, going beyond its immediate readership, TIME Magazine launched TIME for Giving, a community of those keen to provide assistance to a list of charities and causes in need. The key here is for brands to stop thinking about their community just as top-of-the-funnel tactic, and consider it as a long-term, bottom-of-the-funnel strategy (bonding, advocacy, loyalty). Next step is to define and focus on the most valuable customer communities. Community management overall has to be more personal. For example, high-standard of customer service in physical retail stores can translate in the equally high standard customer service via WhatsApp, Zoom, and chat.

Community: It’s What Holds Us Together

A brand community jumped quickly from a “nice to have” to a “must have.” It doesn’t matter the category: a brand it has to find a way to put forward its social mission and values, because that’s what holds the community together. For brands that already maintain communities, the next step is to activate it more, and more often. Check out how WFH and Drawn Together (both Marc Jacobs) and GANNI Talks capitalize on the creativity of their brand’s communities. Or, if underwear is your thing, check out the customers willing to share selfies wearing MeUndies products on Instagram. The David Zwirner Gallery recently launched Platform: New York, an online initiative featuring a community of artists from 12 different galleries. TIME Magazine launched TIME for Giving, a community to connect their readers to a list of charities and causes in need.

Again, almost overnight, the importance of community for brands stretched across the sales funnel from end-to-end.  The activation of community is now a top-of-the-funnel tactic (attention, interest), and a long-term, bottom-of-the-funnel strategy (bonding, advocacy, loyalty). Likewise, brands need to define and focus on the most valuable customer communities. Community management overall has to be more personal. For example, top-notch customer service in physical retail stores can be replicated via WhatsApp, Zoom, and chat.

~~~~~~

Content. Across categories, brands have been pivoting to livestream, lifestyle content en masse. Spurred by Instagram Live, every brand these days is in the business of enriching our lives – through recipes, daily meditations, virtual exercises, design hacks to fix our living quarters, life coaching, movie lists, poetry reading, puppy photos, and hobbies. While it may feel overwhelming at times, this lifestyle content pivot is a good thing: it moves the brands away from product marketing and forces them to explore, define, and capitalize on their cultural and social role. During the February lockdown in China, hashtags #StayInFashionGuide and #StayInPajamaContest drew audience of hundreds of thousands. Stay-in style manuals on WeChat, put forward by KOLs, promoted at-home stylish living and solicited “share your look” submissions on Weibo and held #WorkFromHome outfit contests. While situational, these calls to action open up agile content opportunities post-crisis. There’s also a welcome content shift towards live programming and away from polished campaign imagery. Brands are currently asking artist and photographer friends to help them shoot new content from their homes, or asking their community to create something new every week, like Alexander McQueen did with McQueen Creators. Brands will hopefully embrace this lo-fi approach, and put forward scrappy, live, and real content focused on communal watching and socializing. Community-oriented content tends to do better at the moment (versus the polished influencer one), as the currently predominant memes and aesthetic language demonstrate.

Content. It’s King, I Hear.

Across categories, brands continue to pivot to livestream lifestyle content en masse. Largely by Instagram Live, brands seek to enrich our lives — through recipes, daily meditations, virtual exercises, design hacks to fix our living quarters, life coaching, movie lists, poetry reading, puppy photos and hobbies. Yes: it may feel overwhelming at times. Still, this lifestyle content pivot is a good thing: it moves brands away from product marketing and forces them to explore and define (and monetize) their cultural value and social responsibility. During the February lockdown in China, hashtags #StayInFashionGuide and #StayInPajamaContest drew hundreds of thousands of fans. Stay-in-style manuals on WeChat, put forward by KOLs, promoted at-home stylish living. They even solicited “share your look” submissions on Weibo and held #WorkFromHome outfit contests.

While some contests are pandemic specific, these calls to action open up agile content opportunities in the post-vaccine world. There’s also a welcome content shift away from polished campaign imagery towards live programming.
Brands ask artist and photographer friends to help them shoot new content from their homes, or request community members to create something new every week: see the Alexander McQueen Creators. Brands will hopefully embrace this lo-fi approach, and put forward scrappy, live, and real content focused on communal watching and socializing. Community-oriented content tends to do better today. Seen any memes lately?

~~~~~~

Curation. With their marketing budgets on freeze and their campaign content in a distant future, this is a perfect time for brands to embrace the role of curators and bring forth their unique POV on everything from food to film and theater to architecture and pop culture. There has never been a better moment for a trip down the memory lane and for opening up the product archives. Very few brands are doing this (instead, they opt for tiresome PSAs) In contrast, Rihanna, ever my favorite, launched Fenty Social Club on Insta Live with performances and DJ sets. Somewhat far-fetched is the attempt of an Amsterdam hotel to bring the Easter weekend experience into your home, complete with a curated welcome basked mailed in and virtual concierge on call. With a little better to do, indulging in this hospitality-at-distance expert curation is not completely unreasonable. Airbnb is already doing it with its newly launched online experiences. On a more tangible level, fashion retailers can quickly reskin their landing pages to put forward tops suitable for those frequent Zoom calls. Curation plays a key role here: within a retailers’ entire inventory, ask what are the especially Zoom-able items that consumers will gravitate towards? What are the comfortable bottoms to go with them? What is considered a desirable outfit in these days of working from home is new, and retailers can curate the best combos. Discounts have to follow the same curatorial logic that makes sales seem exclusive and special (e.g. “archive sale”), rather than inventory offloading.

Curation. People Like Us Enjoy Things Like This.

With their marketing budgets on freeze and their campaign content in a distant future, brands can to embrace the role of curators and deliver unique POV on food, film and theater, architecture and pop culture and, well, underwear. Since we loathe the present, let’s celebrate the past! Who’s up for a trip down the memory lane (of Madison Avenue)? Open up the product archives. Very few brands are, alas, ready to make this move. (Please stop with the tiresome PSAs. We get it.) In contrast, my beloved Rihanna launched Fenty Social Club on Insta Live with performances and DJ sets, so you can dance along at home, nostalgic for those days when sweating in close proximity with others was not taboo.

More far-fetched is the attempt of an Amsterdam hotel to bring the Easter weekend experience into your home, complete with a curated welcome basket and virtual concierge on call. Still, for those folks with little better to do, indulging in hospitality-at-a-distance expertise is not completely unreasonable. Airbnb is already doing it with its newly launched online experiences. On a more tangible level, fashion retailers can quickly reskin their landing pages to promote tops suitable for Zoom calls. Curation here is key: across your entire inventory, figure out the especially Zoom-able items that consumers will gravitate towards. Also ask: what bottoms go best with these tops? What is considered a desirable outfit in these days of working from home is new, and retailers can curate the best combos. Discounts have to follow the same curatorial logic that makes sales seem exclusive and special (e.g. “archive sale”), rather than offloading old stock..

~~~~~~

Collaborations. The other week, I saw that Supreme collaborated with Lamborghini. While we may be well past the time when a fashion collab can excite anyone, the new breed of collaborations are springing up. They go beyond short-term commercial and PR buzz towards something with a greater social impact and no less buzz. Dairy company Chobani partnered with coffee seller Trade to support the community of independent coffee roasters. The effort is spurred by the common belief of Chobani and Trade that food (and coffee) can be a force for good. In a similar collaborative vein, aperitif company Haus launched The Restaurant Project, where it partnered with a selected group of restaurants across America to co-create nine aperitifs with their chefs. Hundred percent of profits go to the restaurants. Collaborations like these will become new Supreme + X.

Collaborations: The More the Merrier

As you may know, Supreme is not collaborating with Lamborghini. While we may be well past the time when a fashion collab can excite anyone, a new breed of collaborations is popping up everywhere. They go beyond short-term commercial and PR buzz towards something with a greater social impact (and still plenty of buzz). Dairy company Chobani partnered with coffee seller Trade to support the community of independent coffee roasters. The effort is spurred by their belief that food (and coffee) can be a force for good. In a similar collaborative vein, aperitif company Haus launched The Restaurant Project, for which it partnered with a selected group of restaurants across America (and their chefs) to co-create nine aperitifs. One hundred percent of the profits go to the restaurants. Collaborations like these will become new Supreme + X.

~~~~~~

This crisis is not a short-term acute emergency. It is a call to action for companies to pivot and hit a hard reset on the way they do business. The jobs to be done for a brand, going forward, are communal and social, and the business success is defined through how much a company supports other companies, how much it improves lives of their customers, how much good it does to its community, and what kind of society it reflects. Coronavirus won’t kill brands. Complacency will.

The term crisis still makes sense. In the work of branding, though, it’s not a short-term emergency. It’s a call to action for companies to pivot and hit a hard reset on how they do business. Going forward, branding work is communal and social. Business success is defined by how well a company supports other companies, how much it improves lives of their customers, how much good it does to its community, and what kind of society it creates in its image. Coronavirus won’t kill brands. Complacency will.

# # #

And that’s a wrap. If you like what you see, drop me a line over here.

Thanks!

Happy writing!

Published by Randal Doane

Living the good life in NE Ohio. I dig science and the written word. Let's build something amazing together.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: